Today’s headline in The Australian: Snowy 2.0 hydro scheme could cost $75bn after catastrophic planning failures.

This is my October Estimates hearing with Snowy CEO Mr Barnes and Minister Ayres about the escalating costs, structural problems and ongoing management of the Snowy 2.0 project.

When I asked Mr Barnes in what year the borrowed money and bonds for Snowy 2.0 would be paid off, he admitted he did not have a repayment profile in mind and stated that Snowy Hydro will never reach zero debt or zero bonds.

I pointed out that with the government running financial deficits out past 2050, every cent going into Snowy 2.0 is debt-funded. Mr Barnes confirmed that the current sunk cost is just under $12 billion.

Citing a comment by Robert Gottliebsen in The Australian calling Snowy 2.0 a “laughing stock” with no certainty that it will work, I questioned Mr Barnes on its actual power generation. He confirmed a 20% inefficiency loss, noting the project absorbs 6,000 gigawatt hours a,of power to only produce 5,000 gigawatt hours of electricity for the evening and morning peaks.

The project’s 5,000 construction jobs amount to a government-subsidised employment scheme that decreases national productivity. These workers should instead be reemployed in high-productivity projects like housing, dams, or power stations to reduce the cost of living.

I asked Minister Ayres why the Albanese government continues the project knowing it lacks a proper business case and suffers from increasing technical obstacles. While the Liberals initiated the project out of ignorance, the current government continues the project out of desperation for “renewable” power at any price.

Of course, true to form, Minister Ayres defended the project as one of national importance essential for energy security and grid firming.

When I first started asking about ending the project in 2024 the sunk cost was only $4bn. The more the Government hides from the inevitable, the more it costs taxpayers.

Snowy 2 needs to be put out of its misery and we need to return to building reliable, high-energy-density baseload power using coal.

Transcript

CHAIR: Thank you. Senator Roberts.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you, Mr Barnes, and your staff, for being here again. When will the money borrowed to pay for this project, including bonds, be paid off? What year?  

Mr Barnes: We finance Snowy 2.0 at the company level, so at Snowy Hydro level. Private debt and our shareholder loans, so loans from the government, have a range of debt repayment profiles. I think for the shareholder loan there’s a soon-as-reasonably-practical obligation. You’ve used the word ‘bonds’. We don’t want to specifically use bonds, but I presume you mean in bank debt and shareholder debt.  

Senator ROBERTS: Yes, I do. So what year?  

Mr Barnes: it will be paid off progressively.  

Senator ROBERTS: So what year will it be finished paying off?  

Mr Barnes: We will always hold a debt balance as Snowy Hydro. So we will never go to zero debt.  

Senator ROBERTS: When will you pay off 95 per cent?  

Mr Barnes: We will never go to zero bonds. We will always hold—  

Senator ROBERTS: No, that’s leaving a five per cent balance. So when will you go to 95 per cent paid?  

Mr Barnes: I don’t have a repayment profile in my head.  

Senator ROBERTS: Could you take it on notice?  

Mr Barnes: I don’t think we would be able to model that, to be honest, but we’re happy to take it on notice and see what we can provide. We could probably provide the debt roll-off profile that we will be required to repay or refinance.  

Senator ROBERTS: Whatever you think is needed for good stewardship of taxpayer money.  

Mr Barnes: Yes, of course.  

Senator ROBERTS: It’s not valid to say consolidated revenue has contributed to the cost of Snowy 2.0 when your government is running debt and finance deficits out past 2050. Every cent going into Snowy 2.0 is debt. How much is the total cost of the project, including the interest paid on capital through to—the year you wouldn’t mention, but—  

Mr Barnes: The $12 billion target cost that was approved in 2023 was a $4 billion equity contribution.  

Senator ROBERTS: That was under the first or second year of the Albanese government.  

Mr Barnes: It was in 2024, I think, that it was approved, yes—wherever that is in the political cycle. There was an additional shareholder loan provided which will be required to be paid back in the 2030s. Obviously, we’ve provided this disappointing advice to the government of the higher cost, and they are considering how they may support us through that higher cost. In terms of capitalised interest, again, we finance the organisation at the company level rather than the project level. I think in a prior hearing, I referred to between $2 billion and $3 billion of capitalised interest over the life of the project.  

Senator ROBERTS: Could you total that up on notice, please.  

Mr Barnes: Yes, of course.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you. So you’ve confirmed the current sunk cost is around $12 billion?  

Mr Barnes: Yes. As at the end of June, we were just under $12 billion.  

Senator ROBERTS: And how much more would be incurred if the project was terminated right now, today?  

Mr Barnes: We’ve not done that analysis for public consumption because obviously we are—  

Senator ROBERTS: Have you done the analysis at all?  

Mr Barnes: We have done the analysis of what would we do if we were to change contractor, as has been reported in the press, but we have not done the analysis on what it would cost to terminate the project, given the importance of the project to the grid.  

Senator ROBERTS: Okay, we’ll get back to that again. Robert Gottliebsen in the Australian says: ‘Snowy Hydro 2.0 has destroyed voters’ faith in mega renewable energy projects. It’s a laughing stock.’ That was in the Australian last week. He made the comment in his story about the cost blowout that: Worse still, there is no certainty that the project will actually work. What confidence level, Mr Barnes, do you have that the project will generate the 375,000 megawatt hours of power each year, and, more generally, is there anything in this report to support Robert’s statement?  

Mr Barnes: The project will absolutely work. It doesn’t generate 375 megawatt hours a year; it acts as a storage facility. Our modelling shows that it will actually absorb 6,000 gigawatt hours of electricity and produce 5,000 gigawatt hours of electricity. So it will absolutely work.  

Senator ROBERTS: So that’s the inefficiencies of—  

Mr Barnes: Yes, 20 per cent—  

Senator ROBERTS: So you get less power out of it than you put into it?  

Mr Barnes: Yes, that’s as any battery. To say it produces 375,000 megawatt hours is not a characterisation of its role. Its role is to absorb excess renewables, store those for the time when the grid needs it the most, and it will absolutely do that.  

Senator ROBERTS: Okay. Well, we’ll go into the details at a later date. I note in your release, you say: Closure of the project would cost 5,000 jobs. Those are construction jobs, correct, not permanent jobs?  

Mr Barnes: That’s correct.  

Senator ROBERTS: Is there no other project in Australia that those construction workers could get to work on? For example, the Brisbane, Queensland, Australian Olympics? Housing is desperate for workers, really desperate because the government is bringing in unskilled people. There are dams to build and power stations to build. Have you done any work on how your workforce could transition away from Snowy 2.0?  

Mr Barnes: No.  

Senator ROBERTS: Taxpayers are subsidising an employment scheme. That’s basically what Snowy 2.0 is at the moment. With subsidies, productivity decreases. We’re decreasing the wealth of Australia. You can employ them on projects that will actually increase productivity of Australia. That would be wonderful for improving people’s cost of living; it would be wonderful for higher pay rises that will be noninflationary. But, instead, you’re doing the reverse: You’re decreasing productivity when you could be refarming these people out, releasing them and getting on with higher productivity projects for the benefit of the country.  

Senator Ayres: I think from the government’s perspective this is an important project that will strengthen energy security. You said earlier in a question today that you were worried about firming. This is a very important project in the context of the requirement for firming. As Mr Barnes said, the increasing costs is disappointing.  

Senator ROBERTS: I reckon!  

Senator Ayres: But it’s a consequence of a decision by the previous government to—  

Senator ROBERTS: I grant that we were criticising it back then.  

Senator Ayres: including your leader, Mr Joyce, to race to—  

Senator ROBERTS: What’s he leader of? I thought Pauline Hanson was the leader.  

Senator Ayres: Well, I’ll leave that to you guys. It was a race to a press release and, as Mr Joyce said, done on the back of a beer coaster. There are consequences when large infrastructure projects are run like that.  

Senator ROBERTS: There certainly are. Senator Ayres: Increased costs are inevitable. Once you have a path dependency and poor engineering design, then the rectification costs for that, with the limited number of choices that you have—  

Senator ROBERTS: So you inherited that project. Why didn’t you stop it right then in 2022?  

Senator Ayres: Because it is an important project for the country.  

Senator ROBERTS: With the numbers involved as a load generation? Come on!  

Senator Ayres: Australians do hard things, and we are going to get through this project because it is required to make the country stronger.  

Senator ROBERTS: But most Australians do not do these kinds of things.  

Senator Ayres: It is 65 per cent complete. We will see it through.  

Senator ROBERTS: For miniscule benefit. How much more is going to be lost?  

Senator Ayres: It is not a miniscule benefit. It is a very important national project. We will complete the project. There are consequences from a failure to do the design work by the Abbott, Turnbull and Morrison axis of disinvestment and disaster; that is true. Mr Joyce was a key architect of that, and Mr Taylor was the minister. Mr Taylor at the time said very encouraging things. He said, ‘The economics stack up.’ Mr Taylor said: This is a great day for this region. This is a great day for Snowy Hydro. Most of all, this is a great day for Australia.  

Senator Henderson interjecting—  

Senator Ayres: Well, he was the one who bungled it. CHAIR: Senator Henderson.  

Senator Henderson interjecting—  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson!  

Senator HENDERSON: $25 billion—  

CHAIR: Come to order!  

Senator Ayres: Mr Taylor— Senator Henderson interjecting—  

CHAIR: Sorry, Minister, just one second. Senator Henderson, you interrupted me, and now you have interrupted Senator Roberts. Please don’t interrupt other senators when they’re asking their questions.  

Senator Ayres: I’m not going to be bellowed over. Mr Taylor was the principal architect of this problem. He is the worst energy minister Australia—  

Senator HENDERSON: You’re the worst government—  

Senator Ayres: has ever had.  

Senator HENDERSON: we have ever had in this country.  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson, come to order! Senator Henderson interjecting—  

Senator Ayres: Nothing built.  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson, come to order!  

Senator Ayres: Cost blowouts, delay—  

Senator Henderson interjecting—  

Senator Ayres: Disinvestment and decay.  

Senator Henderson interjecting— 

CHAIR: Senator Henderson!  

Senator Ayres: That is Mr Taylor’s legacy in energy terms.  

Senator Henderson interjecting—  

CHAIR: Well, no, Senator Henderson, he is making an observation about government, but he is answering a question from Senator Roberts. So will everyone please come to order. Minister, please finish your answer, and then we will go back to Senator Roberts for his question.  

Senator Ayres: I think I’m done.  

CHAIR: Senator Roberts.  

Senator ROBERTS: Minister Ayres, your government, the Albanese-Bowen government, endorsed this project when you came to power. You had the authority of the Public Service. You had the whole Public Service at your disposal and you did not do a proper evaluation. The project came out from the Liberals with no policy basis and no options, no alternatives, no business case and no cost-benefit analysis, and it went ahead with no adequate drilling. You knew all of that. You had been sweating on that for years, and yet you still went ahead with it. That’s worse than the Liberals. The Liberals went ahead with it because they were ignorant, but you went ahead with it deliberately. Why?  

Senator Ayres: It’s a project of national importance. Mr Taylor said in October 2019—  

Senator ROBERTS: Why did you? My question is: why did you?  

Senator Ayres: He said: … we made our investment decision after we’d done a cost benefit, and after we’d done the feasibility work. That’s what Mr Taylor said.  

Senator ROBERTS: Heavily redacted.  

Senator Ayres: No, no.  

Senator ROBERTS: Yes, it was.

Senator Ayres: It’s the words that he used in a radio interview.  

Senator ROBERTS: But you knew all this. You knew all this.  

Senator Ayres: He said, ‘Snowy 2.0 is a defining project in our country’s history.’  

Senator HENDERSON: This was authorised under your government, Minister.  

Senator Ayres: The problem for the Liberals and Nationals is they can’t accept responsibility for what they got wrong.  

Senator HENDERSON: You can’t accept the facts. It went off the rails under your banner.  

Senator Ayres: And we will see—  

Senator HENDERSON: You renegotiated the contract—  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson, I’ve asked you—  

Senator HENDERSON: and the whole thing has gone off the rails.  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson, I’ve asked you a number of times to please stop interjecting while the minister is answering Senator Roberts’s questions.  

Senator Ayres: You may be unable to accept responsibility—  

Senator HENDERSON: You can’t accept the facts, Minister.  

Senator Ayres: and you demonstrate that when you shout over the top of me. This is an important project that was set up badly by the previous government. The costs of abandoning it are immense for the Australian community. We will see it through, and we will get it done, and we are relying upon Snowy Hydro to do that work. It is, as Mr Taylor said, an important project.  

Senator ROBERTS: What work, Minister, has your government done since 2022, when it came into power and knew this was a dog, was very badly set up and was very badly managed? It was a mess. What extra work did you do to satisfy yourselves that it was a good project? This is now your project. You’ve had four bloody years to do it and you’ve just gone from mess to mess. What extra work did you do? What extra analysis? What did you do to correct the Liberals’ mistakes?  

Senator Ayres: Mr Barnes will be able to talk to the engagement between the government and Snowy Hydro to make sure that the work required to get this, in an engineering and business and commercial sense, through from one end to the other, literally, is done in the most efficient and effective way possible. It started in a pretty bad place with an unfunded, uncosted project that had, as Mr Barnes has said and I think has been observed by experts, a weakness in terms of its engineering design.  

Senator ROBERTS: Why didn’t you cancel it when you first came to power? Why didn’t you do your due diligence? You’re telling us how bad these people were, and you just accepted that you rubber stamped it blindly.  

Senator Ayres: Them and Mr Joyce, of course, who was engaged in this work too.  

Senator ROBERTS: Why didn’t you stop this project? Why didn’t you review the project?  

Senator Ayres: Because, like with so many things, we had to clean up the Liberals’ messes. That’s what we had to do.  

Senator ROBERTS: Cleaning it up could mean shutting it up.  

Senator Ayres: That’s what we have to do.  

Senator HENDERSON: You’re doing a great job! You did a great job from $6 billion to $25 billion!  

Senator Ayres: No, this is an important project that the country requires, and we spend a lot of our time cleaning up Liberal messes.  

Senator ROBERTS: What due diligence did you do before you decided it was too important? What specifically did you do? This is on you. It started as a mess, that’s true, but this is on you. You could have shut it down in 2022.  

Senator Ayres: Well, we had a choice: stick with a broken contract or reset it and get the project moving.  

Senator ROBERTS: What specifically did you do?  

Senator Ayres: It’s the right decision. I’ll let Mr Barnes go to the detail, if possible, of our very thorough engagement with Snowy Hydro about these questions. Are we happy with the cost increase? Absolutely not. The original contract didn’t have the provisions that would normally be required for penalties for contractors missing cost and performance targets. The problem is this was an Angus Taylor blank cheque. That’s how this began. Now, what’s changed since we’ve taken government—  

Senator HENDERSON: This is completely untrue.  

Senator Ayres: is progress in construction.  

Senator HENDERSON: It was a fixed-price contract, and you changed it to a cost-price contract.  

Senator Ayres: No adequate penalties.  

Senator HENDERSON: A completely open-ended contract.  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson, I’ve asked you a number of times.  

Senator Ayres: An opaque—  

Senator Henderson interjecting—  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson, you do not have the call at this point. It is with Senator Roberts and the minister. Please stop interrupting the line of questioning.  

Senator HENDERSON: It’s a total fabrication, what the minister is saying.  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson.  

Senator HENDERSON: You moved to a cost-plus contract—  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson, come to order.  

Senator HENDERSON: and that’s why it’s blown out.  

CHAIR: Senator Henderson, please stop interjecting in this process. Senator Roberts and the minister are engaged in questioning. We will come to you at the appropriate juncture. Minister.  

Senator Ayres: As Mr Barnes was at pains to go through, characterising this as a cost-plus contract is completely inaccurate. It’s a phrase that is used for completely partisan purposes and deliberately misunderstands the nature of the contract, the reason that having that kind of oversight engaged in the contract is so important and why the way Mr Taylor set this up was so deficient. Every time Mr Taylor was taken to these issues, he ignored the risks. Every time he became aware of the risks, he covered them up. Australians did not know the true state of this project until we took government. It is an important project. We are going to get it done. We are very disappointed with the increase in costs, and you have Mr Barnes here in a position able to answer questions in detail about the work he is on. For example, the power station excavation, which hadn’t even started at the time of the reset, is now almost 90 per cent complete. Tunnelling, bricks and mortar, plant and equipment—real progress, the way that I would measure it in the real world, is being made. It’s hard work that 5,000 Australians are engaged in, and I’m not going to talk down their efforts for a second.  

CHAIR: Senator Roberts.  

Senator ROBERTS: Mr Barnes is going to answer, isn’t he?  

Mr Barnes: What’s the question, sorry?  

Senator ROBERTS: What I put to Senator Ayres. What have you done? Why did you continue the project?  

Mr Barnes: If I can give you a little bit of a chronology. In early 2022—so before my time, but I was able to review the records—the project was making in the order of 0.2 per cent progress per month. The contractor was needing propping up with a cashflow support agreement, and there were $4 billion of claims on the table. Fixed price contracts tend to drive an adversarial approach where you don’t get progress. The first question that is asked when one encounters a problem is: how does this get paid for, because it’s not our fault? The project was not moving forward. In 2023 we moved it to an incentivised target cost model, which has rewards and penalties for performance. Those are very common across Australia; in fact, in the last few years, they are probably the dominant form of construction contract. That allows you to have an open conversation about making progress on the project. In 2023, the advice of myself and the Snowy board—just to be clear, it’s myself and the Snowy board that do the work—was to reset this contract to an ITC model and get progress moving again, and we saw progress double over that period. What we underestimated at the time, and what we got wrong—and I’m not shying away from that—was that we relied on the contractor’s estimate for the balance of the work. In the middle of 2023 we were $4.3 billion through the job, on which the contractor received no margin. At that point the contractor estimated the balance of the job, and that was wrong. We saw that early, and we were clear—I think it was October 2025 when we announced that we would not be able to complete this project for $12 billion. We are making sure that the design immaturity that was enduring is corrected, and that’s what we’ve corrected in the last year. In the last year we’ve had great progress on all the excavation work. I’ve explained what we got wrong in that estimation process, and I’ve explained where I think the project will end. To come to the value of Snowy 2.0, clearly Snowy Hydro is a profit-making organisation. This is a unique asset in a market that does not yet exist. It’s dealing with a range of scenarios for this asset. Earlier in the year we released a report by Baringa Partners which showed what the grid looked like with and without Snowy 2.0. Without Snowy 2.0, reliability is put at risk and prices are higher. We did the counterfactual to eight-hour batteries, which are currently the largest commercial alternative to Snowy 2.0, and one would have had to have 42,000 megawatts of eight-hour batteries. The current cost of that would be over $80 billion. From my perspective and the Snowy Hydro board’s perspective, we’ve got the right contract model to make progress. This project is incredibly valuable to the grid, and the risks of not doing it would risk reliability and higher prices in the electricity market. We’re committed to this project. The Snowy Hydro board and I provided advice to government a few weeks ago of the new cost range and that the project should continue.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you. Another part of the project is to assess not just the cost but the risk. What have you done since you came on board, and what has the Albanese-Bowen government done, since it took power in this country, to understand the risks better? What geophysical drilling have you done at the front of the tunnels?  

Mr Barnes: Snowy Hydro is responsible for delivering this project. The first thing we did was to get transparency and visibility and a contract model that worked. We could not have done the work we’ve done under a fixed-price model, I can assure you; that $4 billion would be $20 billion, and we’d be in court, and the project would not be moving forward. We have a very rigorous cost verification process. We have a number of independent experts embedded within the contractors’ team and our own team. We are adding independent advice to the Snowy board.  

Senator ROBERTS: What have you done to reduce the risk? That’s the biggest thing in this project.  

Mr Barnes: Unfortunately, once the project is sanctioned and you’ve started digging holes and drilling tunnels, you’ve lost the opportunity to do broad geological surveying.  

Senator ROBERTS: Can’t you do that ahead of the drilling machine, to at least clarify that?  

Mr Barnes: For the areas that we are concerned about, the famous TBM Florence is currently ahead of a naturally occurring asbestos zone, and there’s drilling ahead of the machine to deal with that. TBM Monica, which will traverse the Long Plain Fault Zone, has subsequently had full length of the drive geological surveying—so that’s the full couple of kilometres where we think this zone is tricky. The new tunnel boring machine that we acquired to deal with the Long Plain Fault Zone—which by the way, would not have been a decision you would have made under a fixed-price contract; you would have let poor old Florence get there and fail, and would have many years of delay. TBM Monica has got the most advanced probe in technology, along with dewatering technology to prepare the ground ahead. There’s a lot of governance oversight and there are a lot of physical things we’ve done on the ground to assure ourselves we can continue to get this job to move. The team in Snowy that’s responsible for this—at the time of the reset it was maybe 30 or 40 people. I now have 200 people embedded on this project.  

Senator ROBERTS: What’s the net present value now of this project?  

Mr Barnes: We haven’t released the business case at this point, because the job to date was to get advice to government to work out the subsequent support.  

Senator ROBERTS: Still no business case?  

Mr Barnes: We have done a range of economic modelling both on the cost range and the return range, and that will inform the government support over the next few months.  

Senator ROBERTS: What will it cost total—I think it’s now $22 billion estimated, plus contingencies—and what will it save per year with the miniscule amount of electricity it’s going to produce per year?  

Mr Barnes: Snowy 2.0 does a number of things. The first thing is it absorbs excess renewables. If you read some reports out of the UK recently about the massively escalating cost of what they call turndown payments—so when a wind farm or solar farm can’t produce because the demand is not there, because the—  

Senator ROBERTS: Which we told everyone about.  

Mr Barnes: Snowy 2.0 is fantastic at absorbing that excess production. That allows 6,000 to 7,000 megawatts of wind farms and solar farms to be developed. So that’s point No. 1, that it brings cheap energy to the grid. Point No. 2 is that Snowy 2.0 then stores that energy for periods when demand is higher, in the evening. More importantly, when we get two or three days, or up to a week, of low wind and solar production, the grid does not solve without Snowy 2.0 in those circumstances. It then provides system strength services. So when the big coal plants retire and the big spinning machines are not there, Snowy 2.0 will provide that service. In addition to that, the effect on wholesale prices is to reduce those because we are not bringing on what might be more expensive gas or overinvesting in batteries and renewables to provide that service. Then the final one, which does not accrue to Snowy Hydro of course, is the broad economic benefits through the construction phase  

Senator ROBERTS: It seems ludicrous to me that you compare batteries, because batteries are not industrial scale. You also have admitted there are out-of-peak periods that are out of sync with demand, so we are going to plunge $50 billion into this mess just to overcome an inherent flaw in solar and wind. What’s wrong with just building a coal-fired power station? You could be done with it.  

Mr Barnes: My job as CEO of Snowy Hydro is to power Australia’s renewable energy future. That’s in our statement of expectation, and that’s what Snowy 2.0 will do.  

Senator ROBERTS: As an adviser in 2017, I called for the project to be scrapped. As a senator, on 25 October 2023—three years ago—I called for it to be scrapped. At the time, sunk cost was only $4 billion against a project cost of $12 billion. Minister, in your pursuit of an ideological goal, net zero, that other countries are moving away from, your government has wasted $12 billion on this foolhardy project and wants to waste another $40 billion including transmission lines which were never imagined to be needed. And who knows how much there will be in interest payments over the next 30 years? We haven’t got a figure on that. Minister, will you put this idiot idea out of its misery and get back to building baseload power generation.  

Senator Ayres: Well, I wouldn’t use that kind of language to describe the people and the project that is going on here. It’s an important project for Australia. The previous government—and I’m sharply critical of their failure to plan—recognised this was an important project for the country. The alternative, as you say, is wall-to-wall outdated technology being installed to take Australia backwards, lift our costs, make us uncompetitive and force industry offshore. Installing coal-fired power, which appears to be your alternative proposition—  

Senator ROBERTS: The footprint is incredibly small and there’s high energy density.  

Senator Ayres: I listened patiently to what you said, even though I sharply disagree with it—all of it. I don’t want to be interrupted; I didn’t interrupt you. Your prescription—Senator Hanson’s prescription and Mr Joyce’s prescription—for the country is to take us backwards, to lift our costs, to force industry offshore and to take us to lower growth, lower employment and a lower wages future. I understand that’s what you want to do, but that’s not what the Albanese government is going to do. We’re going to finish this project because it’s in the national interest to finish it. Now, you’ll have to put up with, over the course of the next short while, Senator Watt, who’s going to be delighted to—  

Senator ROBERTS: Minister, how did we go from the cheapest electricity in the world to the most expensive?  

Senator Ayres: I don’t want to spend the night explaining how technology evolves. Some things that were cheap in 1950 are expensive in 2026.  

Senator ROBERTS: Coal-fired power is the cheapest in the world. And it’s reliable—  

Senator Ayres: Well, I don’t know how to—  

Senator ROBERTS: and synchronous—  

Senator Ayres: persuade you, Senator Roberts—  

Senator ROBERTS: and stable.  

Senator Ayres: because I know you’re not listening. Technology changes. The relative economic cost of technology changes. There are productivity changes. That’s the first point. The second point is Australia has a different geography to other countries. So our relative competitive advantage is different to other countries.  

Senator ROBERTS: That means it’s all the more important we have high energy density.  

Senator Ayres: We have limitless space and enormous wind and solar resources. You would not want to be anywhere else on earth but Australia.  

Senator ROBERTS: Low energy density is scattered.  

Senator Ayres: Now, I understand you want to take the joint backwards. You want to lower our future growth and to lower our future productivity. Keep on with it, but that is not the approach that this government is going to take. 

At Senate Estimates, Labor admitted there are around 80,000 people in Australia without a valid visa, nearly 84,000 migration cases backed up in the tribunal system, and widespread concerns about visa hopping and migration loopholes.

They also confirmed new measures to restrict student dependents, crack down on visa abuse and increase removals of unlawful non-citizens.

For years, One Nation has warned that Australia’s migration system was being exploited while governments looked the other way.

Now Labor is slowly adopting the very measures it once dismissed.

The difference is that One Nation wants to fix the problem. Labor is still trying to explain how it happened.

Transcript

CHAIR: Senator Roberts.  

Senator ROBERTS: What measures are being taken to send the illegals out of Australia?  

Ms Sharp: Senator, Mr Thomas will no doubt come up and join me at the table. The government has announced that it’s funding an additional 250 beds in immigration detention. That is going to assist us to much more actively target people who have no right to remain—visa overstayers, predominantly. We have also received additional funding for around 100 additional officers, predominantly for our field removals and detention capability. That will allow us to have the additional people to go out and do the work to identify individuals who are overstaying their visas. We will also be communicating much more proactively with people as they approach the end of their visa period, and immediately after, to ensure they understand that, when their visa expires, they either need a new visa or need to leave and that, if they don’t leave, the immigration detention system is there and it will be used.  

Mr M Thomas: As Ms Sharp said, it’s really maximising the engagement with this cohort to encourage self departure as much as possible. Where people do not self-depart, we look at detention and removal. But we aim to maximise the number of unlawful non-citizens here leaving the country at the end of their migration pathway.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you for your answer. Would it be fair to say that there are two problems here? One is you’re addressing 80,000 people who are here illegally with 250 beds. So there are two aspects. One is stopping the future illegals and one is getting rid of the current illegals. Is that fair?  

Ms Foster: That’s right, Senator, and I think there are a number of amplifying factors. Depending on how quickly we can turn people over from detention to removal, obviously, those beds can produce a lot more than— it’s not 250 a year, for example. It’s rotating.  

Senator ROBERTS: It’s rotating. I get it.  

Ms Foster: If, on average, for example, it took us a month to prepare all the papers and get someone involuntarily out, then that’s still 250 by 12. What we’re finding is that some people are leaving more quickly than that. So that’s one factor. The second is that our historical data shows us that, for every person we remove, there is a flow-on effect of people who understand what might happen to them. It’s not advantageous to be removed. It affects your future visa prospects. So there’s a factor of somewhere around six or seven per cent of people who leave voluntarily in relation to the number of people that we remove.  

Ms Sharp: Six or seven times.  

Ms Foster: Sorry, six or seven times.  

Senator ROBERTS: We’ve covered that.  

Ms Foster: And then there is the impact of the communications activity and the knowledge that will get around in communities about what’s happening to people that we think will also add to that number. This has been a sticky problem for many, many years. We believe that this combination of measures will allow us to start to make a real impact on that number.  

Senator ROBERTS: You should contact Senator Hanson’s office, because our policy comprehensively addresses this, but we’ll move on. What measures are being taken to stop preachers of hate within the Islamic community?  

Senator Watt: I’m very glad you asked, Senator Roberts, because—  

Senator ROBERTS: Good. I hope you’ve got news— 

 Senator Watt: You might remember my mentioning at a previous estimates hearing that earlier this year, when we introduced legislation to make it easier to deport hate preachers, you, Senator Hanson and every other One Nation senator voted against that legislation.  

Senator ROBERTS: Because of your poison pills in your legislation! You’ve got to get out of this habit.  

CHAIR: Senator Roberts, let the minister answer.  

Senator Watt: As I’ve pointed out, the other major aspect of that legislation was also cracking down on Neo Nazis, so I’m still waiting to hear what it was about that legislation you didn’t like. Was it that it was taking on—  

Senator ROBERTS: I’m happy to sit down in discussion with you.  

Senator Watt: Neo-Nazis or deporting hate preachers? I think this is the third or fourth time I’ve made these points.  

Senator ROBERTS: So when do you expect Islamic preachers to be sent out of the country?  

Senator Watt: Well, it would help to have your support for the legislation that we passed. We actually got support from the coalition. I’ll acknowledge that. But you voted against the legislation—  

Senator ROBERTS: Because of the poison pills in the bill.  

Senator Watt: that makes it easier to deport hate preachers.  

Senator ROBERTS: You can’t get honest legislation through without blackmail, and we’re not going to fall for blackmail.  

Senator Watt: You voted against deporting hate preachers.  

Senator ROBERTS: Correct.  

Senator Watt: It couldn’t be clearer than that.  

Senator ROBERTS: We voted against the poison pill in your—  

Senator Watt: What was the poison pill?  

Senator ROBERTS: There were many poison pills.  

Senator Watt: Can you give me an example?  

Senator ROBERTS: You’ve put it in industrial relations. You’ve put it in immigration. You’ve put it—  

Senator Watt: Can you give me one example?  

Senator ROBERTS: No. How many persons on skilled worker visas in Australia are working in their identified skilled professional field?  

Mr Willard: Senator, in terms of temporary skilled visa holders, it’s a requirement of their visa that they work in the role for which they were recruited. So most of those temporary visa holders are working in their field. In terms of permanent visas, there’s a recent release from the Bureau of Statistics which is ‘Migrant settlement outcomes’, which talks about permanent skilled entrants. It has some figures in comparison to the Australian population around how those permanent skilled entrants are tracking. In terms of employment rate—and this is the employment to population ratio—the figure for permanent skilled entrants is 82 per cent and the figure for the Australian population is 74 per cent. There are a couple of other key figures there. English proficiency is 91 per cent for permanent skilled entrants and 92 per cent for the Australian population, and a non-school qualification is 80 per cent permanent skilled residents and 36 per cent for the Australian population. This is a Bureau of Statistics publication that was released in September.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you. What is the extent of people entering Australia as skilled workers who hold worthless or forged qualifications? Do you check qualifications on their application?  

Mr Willard: We do check qualifications. Any instance where there’s a fraudulent qualification submitted in an application would result in visa refusal. The vast majority of skilled migrants are highly skilled people who hold high-level qualifications.  

Senator ROBERTS: When do you envisage the backlog on visa appeals to be resolved by the Administrative Review Tribunal?  

Ms Sharp: There was some very useful legislation passed by the parliament earlier this year that will assist the Administrative Review Tribunal to get through the student backlog. That was a large group of student visa applications that had built up there. They are in the process of now rolling out that change, which is allowing them to dismiss matters on the papers without holding a hearing. You would need to directly ask them about how many months they think it will take to clear that backlog, but they are making some positive progress.  

Senator ROBERTS: So you wouldn’t be able to give me an idea of how long it’ll take?  

Ms Sharp: No, I really think that’s a matter for the Administrative—  

Senator ROBERTS: What are the numbers in the ART appeals process?  

Mr Willard: I’ve got the ART report. These are their figures, but the figure I have here—this is a case-load report for 1 July to 31 August 2026. I’m reading the ‘On hand at period end’ figure. There are 54,000 student visas, or just under that figure.  

Senator ROBERTS: Then there are other categories as well.  

Mr Willard: There are other categories.  

Senator ROBERTS: What’s the total backlog that the ART is facing at the moment?  

Mr Willard: Again, I’m reading their figure to you. I haven’t been able to verify all of this, but the figure is 83,847 under a heading ‘Migration’.  

Senator ROBERTS: Are you aware of the massive current rort of the maritime crew visa subclass 988 for domestic trade and the active abuse of the subclass 400 short stay specialist and subclass 482 temporary skill shortage visas, to flood domestic waters with cheap foreign mariners doing the work that hundreds of highly skilled Australian mariners are qualified and willing to do?  

Mr Willard: There are a range of safeguards and measures, in respect of all of those visas, that are designed to prevent misuse of the visas. There are always some instances of noncompliance in respect of visas, but, for the large part, it’s very high levels of compliance that we record.  

Senator ROBERTS: Multinational companies are falsely claiming, we’ve been advised, that they cannot find local employees and then hiring low-cost foreign mariners under visa subclasses 400 and 482. There is no skills shortage in this field in Australia. There are many captains, mates and engineers seeking work in Australia.  

Ms Sharp: If you have specific examples, you’re very welcome to send them through to us and we can have a look at them. If there are businesses that should be on our radar, we’d welcome you sending those through.  

Senator ROBERTS: Is this rort currently being investigated? Are you aware of it?  

Mr Willard: Where there are instances of concern raised then we do look into them, and we do engage with employers where there are concerns raised about their practices.  

Senator ROBERTS: That’s encouraging, because the foreign workers’ wages go straight out of our country.  

CHAIR: Senator Roberts, to give you an indication, you are at your 10 minute block.  

Senator ROBERTS: Yes. This will be my last question. Minister, what are you doing to target the huge number of students currently here in Australia—way in excess of the numbers of beds at universities for international students? They, and their families and dependants, are taking up beds and houses that could be filled with Australians. What are you doing about their dependants, their families? What are you doing about people who are here with no real skills? What are you doing about graduates? One Nation has an answer for all of these.  

Senator Watt: And you’ll have a chance to put your answers to the public.  

Senator ROBERTS: We look forward to that.  

Senator Watt: We have already taken action to reduce international student numbers, over the last couple of years, but the recent announcements by Minister Burke involved further action around student visas. To give you a couple of examples, we’re cracking down on what’s referred to as ‘visa hopping’, so student visa holders will not be able to apply for another student visa onshore unless they fit a small number of categories. Most temporary visa holders will be prevented from applying for a student visa onshore. Most international students and temporary graduates will be prevented from bringing family members with them to Australia. So there are a range of new measures that we’re taking in addition to ones that we’ve already taken.  

Ms Sharp: In addition to that, from 1 July 2026, the visa application charge for new student visas and temporary graduate visas was increased by 25 per cent. The government allocated $19.8 million to extend the student visa cancellation team to ensure that we can identify and cancel visas of students who are not doing the right thing. Finally, the government is also applying a higher degree of scrutiny over particular providers that are offering courses that are not doing what they’re saying—what they should be doing. So, recently, Minister Hill issued three notices of intention to suspend particular courses and providers.  

Senator ROBERTS: Minister, I must say it’s very, very pleasing and gratifying to see that the current government is taking tiny steps to catch up with One Nation. But when are you going to start acknowledging that you are the government—you’ve been the government for almost half a decade—instead of blaming the previous lot?  

Senator Watt: The fact is that, when we came to office, we had a broken migration system—  

Senator ROBERTS: Half a decade ago.  

Senator Watt: Yes. Let me finish. The fact is: when we came to office, we had a broken migration system that was full of rorts, that led to what you’ve described as the highest migration numbers that we’ve seen. Since that time, we’ve taken a whole range of measures that have almost halved net overseas migration—  

Senator ROBERTS: You’ve come down to the second-highest and the third-highest! Well done!  

Senator Watt: It’s well below that now, because of the action that we’ve taken.  

Senator HANSON: They were the highest—  

Senator ROBERTS: Yours were the highest, by far. 

No Australian parent should have to spend years fighting to see their own child.

Japan’s joint custody reforms have been hailed as progress, but at Senate Estimates officials conceded they won’t automatically help the families already torn apart.

Today, 16 Australian parents are still seeking contact with 23 children in Japan

For the parents still waiting, justice delayed is time they’ll never get back.

I won’t stop fighting for these families and doing everything I can to help reunite them.

https://youtu.be/fdYE6LfJHbc

Transcript

CHAIR: Senator Roberts, I understand you’ve got some questions on Japan.  

Senator ROBERTS: I have, thank you, CHAIR. Thank you for appearing today. These questions, Senator Wong, are follow-ups from earlier questions regarding child support issues where children have been taken— stolen, rather—from a parent to now reside in Japan. I respect and admire the Japanese people. This is a difficult issue, and I understand it’s sensitive, Senator Wong. We’ve discussed that in the past. What’s changed, and what remains proposed in Australian child support law related to stolen children resident in Japan?  

Senator Wong: I don’t think we can speak to child support legislation here. What we can speak to is the work we’ve done to advocate for the consideration of joint custody arrangements. I think that’s the term that was used. The child support agency is not part of this portfolio.  

Senator ROBERTS: Is someone going to speak to that?  

Ms McGregor: We recognise the profound and continuing impact of parent-child separation on Australian families. This is a very difficult and sensitive issue, as you note. We have been working with Japan for a number of years now on their joint custody reforms. They have been in effect since 1 April this year. They’re a very important step forward for Japan. They will not automatically change existing sole custody arrangements or resolve all legacy cases. What we have done, are doing and will continue to do is provide consular assistance to affected families. We’re also advocating that the reforms be implemented in a way that supports children having relationships with both parents where that is in the best interests of the child.  

Senator ROBERTS: Senator Wong, do you or the department give advice regarding changes of laws in this country on this matter?  

Senator Wong: Sorry, changes of Australian law or changes of Japanese law?  

Senator ROBERTS: Changes of Australian law, initially. What risks and representations aren’t being considered?  

Senator Wong: I’m sorry, Senator, I don’t quite understand. Is this adoption or is this joint custody?  

Senator ROBERTS: Joint custody  

Ms McGregor: That would be a matter for the individuals in consultation with their lawyers. We do not provide legal advice as part of our consular service.  

Senator ROBERTS: Are you giving advice in regard to the Australian government to change laws in Australia?  

Senator Wong: Oh, I see. Sorry. I thought you meant to individuals.  

Senator ROBERTS: No.  

Senator Wong: No, that would be a matter for the portfolio, probably DSS.  

Senator ROBERTS: Wouldn’t they consult with you?  

Ms McGregor: That would be a matter for Services Australia.  

Senator ROBERTS: Surely they’d need to understand the situation in Japan. Surely you’d be giving them advice.  

Senator Wong: Senator, I don’t quite understand. I’m sorry, I don’t quite understand the point you’re making. What we have contributed to—I’ve raised it with a number of foreign ministers and we really appreciate the way in which Japan has progressed this—is we have spoken about our approach of joint custody. My recollection is that we had a Family Court judge go to Japan to talk through our legislative framework et cetera What are you asking? What are you saying should occur here in Australia?  

Senator ROBERTS: What we’ve seen, Senator Wong, is wrongful removal or retention of children, unfulfilled return orders and prolonged obstruction of safe contact. Are these being assessed in reform designed in Australia? Our laws. Are you giving advice on these?  

Senator Wong: We don’t give advice on child support laws. The usual practice of government is that if the department responsible believes it needs to engage with another portfolio, then that is done. I don’t have personal knowledge of where the DSS has done that. Are you suggesting that the child support laws should be changed? Is that the assertion?  

Senator ROBERTS: I just want to know if anything is being considered in regard to that, Senator Wong.  

Senator Wong: Well, that is a matter for the Department of Social Services.  

Senator ROBERTS: You’ve had no interaction with Australian lawmakers on this topic?  

Senator Wong: Well, I am an Australian lawmaker—  

Senator ROBERTS: I know that, but on this topic.  

Senator Wong: and so are you. But I don’t have knowledge of a reform where we’ve engaged on this.  

Senator ROBERTS: Okay. Thank you, that’s all I wanted to know. What representations came from Japan or other foreign governments, and how are they being considered?  

Senator Wong: On what issue?  

Senator ROBERTS: On the abduction of Australian children who now reside in Japan.  

Senator Wong: I think the way I’d approach that is, again, to go back to what I’ve spoken to you about before and that I referenced just then. Japan had a very different legal system in relation to this issue. That obviously meant that we had parents in Australia, or Australian parents, who were separated from their children and that was extremely distressing. We’ve advocated consistently and we’ve sought to provide consular support. We’ve spoken to them about legislative reform and we welcome their reforms from April 2026. We contributed by sharing our experience and our expertise in family law and dispute resolution. I don’t know that I can add to that. I don’t know if officials have anything further on that?  

Ms McGregor: I think only to say that we’ve raised this at the very highest levels of the Japanese system over a number of years.  

Senator ROBERTS: Will you continue to be doing that to advance the cause?  

Senator Wong: Which?  

Senator ROBERTS: Because there’s a sense that these reforms are minor. They’re welcome, but they’re minor.  

Ms McGregor: We’ll continue to advocate and we’ll also continue to provide consular support to affected families. We’re currently assisting 16 parents in relation to 23 children. Since 2004—that’s how far back this assistance goes—we’ve assisted parents in relation to 90 children.  

Senator ROBERTS: Are you able to tell me how big the issue is? For example, numbers of children affected, number of families affected, the amounts presumably collected for child custody payments?  

Ms McGregor: I refer to my previous answer: we’re currently assisting 16 parents in relation to 23 children and we’ve assisted parents in relation to 90 children since 2004. So we provide that consular assistance. We continue to advocate for the implementation of the reforms in the best interests of the affected children in these cases.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you. How do disputed care determinations, qualifying contact costs, adjustments and direct payment credits operate internationally, including after interim protections expire?  

Ms McGregor: Senator— Senator  

ROBERTS: Does that vary from country to country?  

Ms McGregor: Custody and access decisions are matters for the Japanese courts. I would imagine that the situation varies for different countries, so I wouldn’t speak to the broader global picture.  

Senator ROBERTS: What mechanisms support safe contact and enforcement of relevant orders, and with what outcomes?  

Ms McGregor: Senator, again, they would be matters for the courts.  

Senator ROBERTS: Have you considered proposed departure restrictions—assessing necessary child contact travel here in Japan as distinct from debt evasion—and what exemptions or review would be available? Are these matters you can influence?  

Ms McGregor: Yes, again, those are matters for the courts. And, in terms of Australian laws, they’re matters for other agencies.  

Senator ROBERTS: Senator Wong, the last time we spoke on this difficult issue, it was indicated that you had limited knowledge about seminars run in Brisbane for Japanese parents about taking children to live in Japan. One such seminar was held on 16 February 2024 at the Consulate-General of Japan in Brisbane. Attendees included Phoenix Law & Associates and an official from the Hague Convention Division in Japan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs. A representative of an organisation called ‘International Social Security Australia’ had been invited but pulled out beforehand. I’m just passing on advice because you had no information.  

Senator Wong: This was a Japanese government event in 2024?  

Senator ROBERTS: Held at the Japanese consulate-general with representatives from Japan.  

Senator Wong: A couple of years ago.  

Senator ROBERTS: On 16 February 2024. Can you tell us any more about the April 2026 joint custody reforms in Japan? I know it’s not long ago—only six months. Can you give parents hope?  

Ms McGregor: Senator, those reforms did come into effect on 1 April. As noted previously, we have done a lot of work with Japan both prior to that date, sharing expertise in terms of our experience in this very complex area. They are an important step. But now, of course, implementation lies ahead. We’ll continue to work with Japan on that process. As noted previously, it will not automatically change existing sole-custody arrangements or resolve all legacy cases. But we are continuing to support Japan in this process to make sure that implementation occurs in a way that supports children having relationships with both parents, where it is in their interests.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you. How will you assess the impact of these changes on Australian children and parents once more time elapses?  

Ms McGregor: We welcome all feedback on our consular assistance. There are channels through which that feedback can be collected, including through our posts overseas and the Smartraveller website, as well as the conversations that we have with our clients. Through those channels, we will continue to gather information on the experience of our clients and use that to inform our engagement with Japanese authorities. That includes through regular consultations that we have with Japan on consular issues as well as other bilateral engagements that we have.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you. Thank you, CHAIR. 

Should Australian taxpayers be forced to fund gender-transition surgeries through Medicare?

At Senate Estimates, I pressured Health Department officials on a proposal to add gender-affirming surgeries to Medicare. Despite the push for taxpayer funding, officials admitted there are currently no cost estimates, and the proposal is still being assessed for its clinical effectiveness and value for money.

I welcome the clear assurance from officials that the decision will be made on the basis of the medical case for the surgeries. Medicare exists to treat illness and save lives, not to bankroll the surgical removal of healthy body parts.

Transcript

CHAIR: We will recommence outcome 2, starting with Senator Roberts.  

Senator ROBERTS: Application 1754, surgical procedures for gender affirmation in adults, is to the medical benefits advisory committee. There was a news report on the weekend, titled, ‘Plastic surgeons push to fund 30 transgender surgeries on Medicare amid safety concerns’. It’s an application by the Australian Association of Plastic Surgeons to have multiple types of transgender surgeries listed on Medicare so they can be performed free of charge to a patient in a public hospital, subject to resource availability. Is this correct?  

Mr McCabe: Yes, the Australian Society of Plastic Surgeons has made an application to the Medical Services Advisory Committee for gender-affirming surgeries for adults.  

Senator ROBERTS: In effect, if it’s successful, this means all taxpayers are paying for these surgeries, whether they agree with transgenderism or not. What will be the annual cost to taxpayers if the application is approved?  

Mr McCabe: It’s probably important to note that this application is very early in its process. The Medical Services Advisory Committee is meeting again later in November to discuss the clinical efficacy of these surgeries. Then we’d have to get to, in due course, the cost effectiveness. We’re a while away from any decisions or recommendations out of the committee, and, ultimately, any recommendations would be a decision of government. We’re a long way away from that.  

Senator ROBERTS: So there are no cost estimates yet?  

Mr McCabe: Not at this stage, no.  

Senator ROBERTS: The title of the application includes the phrase ‘gender incongruence’, which is ‘a medical and psychological term defined by the World Health Organisation as a marked and persistent mismatch between an adult’s experienced or expressed gender and their assigned sex at birth’. Minister, is this use of ‘assigned sex at birth’ consistent with departmental language on this issue, or has the applicant jumped ahead of the department’s position?  

Senator Green: Senator, I can’t speak for the applicant. I certainly know that there is some medical advice that we can give you about the right terminology in the particular context that you’re talking about.  

Senator ROBERTS: Terminology is a good word, Minister, because it’s an accurate word. What’s happening, according to an article I read in the Weekend Australian, which is the only newspaper I read—  

Senator Green: Not the Courier Mail?  

Senator ROBERTS: Sometimes. They’re about changing the language, which is what a lot of advocates try to do, to make it sweeter and more palatable. They’re changing established terms like gender dysphoria and making it ‘gender incongruence’. Minister, for clarity, is it the policy of the department of health that sex is not a biological fact but rather is assigned and not determined at birth? Is sex assigned or determined at birth?  

Senator Green: We can take you through the definitions that are given. I think the most relevant one would be—is it the NHMRC definition? But this is obviously something that is reviewed from time to time.  

Senator ROBERTS: The definition of male and female, of sex, is reviewed?  

Senator Green: No, no—the terminology that you’re using, which is used by medical practitioners. I think we’re talking about two different things. But the chief medical officer can probably answer that for you.  

Prof. Kidd: Sure. Just on the issue of gender incongruence, this is a term that’s included, as you’re mentioning, in the World Health Organization’s International Classification of Diseases. So it’s a very well-established term. It’s not new terminology—  

Senator ROBERTS: Excuse me; why does something used by the World Health Organization make it well established?  

Prof. Kidd: Because it’s used all over the world.  

Senator ROBERTS: Instead of gender dysphoria?  

Prof. Kidd: Gender dysphoria is used as well. Gender incongruence is—I can read the definitions, if you like, or I can share them with you out of session.  

Senator ROBERTS: Reading them is fine.  

Prof. Kidd: Gender incongruence is ‘an objective difference or misalignment between your internal sense of gender and your biological sex assigned at birth’. Gender dysphoria is ‘the psychological distress, discomfort or anxiety that can result from gender incongruence…not everyone with gender incongruence experiences severe distress and dysphoria is not an inherent requirement to identify as transgender’.  

Senator ROBERTS: So, Minister, can sex be changed by surgery?  

Senator Green: Senator, the definitions that we’re talking about—sex is what someone is. That’s their characteristic at birth. Then we talk about gender in a few different ways, and that’s not necessarily dependent on whether someone does or doesn’t have surgery. I’d probably point you—we’re getting outside the realm of the health department’s responsibilities here—to state and territory based laws that look at certain characteristics that people have when deciding whether to issue a new birth certificate, for example. Then, of course, the Sex Discrimination Act recognises a range of people’s attributes.  

Senator ROBERTS: Attributes as opposed to sex at birth, which is chromosome—  

Senator Green: It recognises gender and the attributes that relate to those genders.  

Senator ROBERTS: So because it’s in the law, it’s right?  

Senator Green: It’s a law that’s been in place for quite some time, Senator.  

Senator ROBERTS: Since 2011, I think, with Julia Gillard.  

Senator Green: Supported by the opposition at the time as well—yes.  

Senator ROBERTS: And they’re ruing the day. Decisions to add an item to Medicare are made using a legislative instrument in this case. Can you confirm the decision will be dealt with by way of a disallowable instrument?  

Senator Green: That’s a question for the department. I’m not sure what that legislative instrument usually would be.  

Senator ROBERTS: Is it going to be legislation or regulation?  

Senator Green: We’ll confirm that for you, Senator, so that you’re fully aware.  

Mr McIntyre: Senator, I’d suggest, though, that we’re getting ahead of ourselves. At the moment, there’s an application, and, as an application to MSAC, there’s a wide range of documents, including summaries of all of the consultations that MSAC has had, that are available on MSAVC’s website, which is with the department of health. You can go there and read the various positions of the different interested stakeholders. Those are the issues that MSAC will consider again at their November meeting as they progress the application. All of this is before any advice has been put to government. The form of legislation or regulation would only be set if the application were recommended, and we’re not at that point yet.  

Senator ROBERTS: Okay, thank you. If it is a disallowable instrument, I’m going to look forward to that debate.  

Mr McCabe: Just to add to Mr McIntyre’s testimony, the Medical Services Advisory Committee needs to make assessments about the clinical efficacy of these surgeries, which I’ve mentioned before, and then they will need to make judgements on the cost effectiveness. It’s not an automatic assumption or decision that they will then recommend to government for these services to be established on Medicare. That is still something that is in deliberations, and we are very early in the assessment process.  

Senator ROBERTS: Right now, we’ve got things changing overseas; we’ve got things changing in Australia. More and more people are turning to peer reviewed papers which are questioning affirmation as a treatment of gender dysphoria. Will the council be consulting peer reviewed papers and specialists?  

Mr McCabe: The way this committee works is that the applicant needs to put evidence to that committee in their submissions that step through, as I said, the clinical efficacy and then, ultimately, the cost effectiveness of the procedures that they’re proposing. I believe—but I’d need to double-check with my colleagues—that there has been some information, and Mr McIntyre indicated that there are a whole heap of submissions already available on our website that explain what’s been done previously. But, as I’ve reiterated, we are very early in the process of this assessment, and, ultimately, the committee will have to deliberate and make decisions about whether they want to recommend services.  

Senator ROBERTS: So are the submissions made to the council open to the public?  

Mr Murray: Yes, they’re on the website. If you go onto the Medical Services Advisory Committee website, you can find the application. You can also find the information on what MSAC has done to date, which includes public consultations, targeted consultations and reports prepared for MSAC to help them understand the evidence and other pathways and issues with this proposal.  

Senator ROBERTS: Okay. Thank you. Mr Comley, I want to compliment the witnesses for their answers.  

Mr Comley: Thank you. 

No Right to Be Here: Time to Act

At Senate Estimates, Labor admitted it’s deliberately slowing visa processing to reduce migration numbers and regain control of who comes into Australia.

They also confirmed there are around 80,000 non-citizens in Australia without a valid visa and acknowledge widespread “visa hopping” through the system.

For years, One Nation has been calling for controlled migration, and end to visa loopholes and the removal of people who have no right to be here.

Now even Labor is adopting measures that sound remarkably familiar.

When it comes to immigration, One Nation isn’t following the agenda. We’re setting it.

Transcript

CHAIR: Senator Roberts.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you for appearing. Before we start, Ms Foster, thank you for the briefing on Friday, I think it was, last week. We’ve heard via the media that there is currently a ‘go slow’ practice occurring in the processing of some visa applications. Which types of visas are currently being processed slowly?  

Ms Sharp: Minister Burke, in his Press Club address, made it clear that there was slower processing being applied to the working holiday-maker visa. That has stabilised now at around a three-month processing time for all working holiday-maker visa applications where there’s a specified work requirement, which is that every everyone is required, if they want to do a second year, to work in a regional area. For working holiday-maker visa applicants from the UK, who do not have the specified work requirement, those are still being processed more slowly.  

Senator ROBERTS: How many such applications have had delayed processing?  

Ms Sharp: Mr Willard might be able to help you with that.  

Mr Willard: I might be able to give you some numbers in terms of numbers of visas on hand—the number of visas processed in the working holiday-maker visa space—if you’ll bear with me. In 2026-27, to 31 August, we’ve granted 22,377 working holiday visas. When we look at the active applications on hand, there are 48,752 on hand.  

Senator ROBERTS: How many was that?  

Mr Willard: 48,752.  

Senator ROBERTS: Applications on hand?  

Mr Willard: Yes.  

Senator ROBERTS: Why are they being delayed again?  

Mr Willard: Ms Sharp just outlined.  

Ms Sharp: We have got historically high, very high, levels of working holiday-maker visas in Australia currently. The purpose of slowing the processing and stabilising the processing time with that three-month delay is to moderate the growth rate of working holiday-maker numbers in Australia. Longer term, we’re moving towards managing that number so that it’s not completely demand-driven through the use of ballots going forward. 

Senator ROBERTS: It’s an official policy. It was directed by Minister Burke.  

Ms Sharp: It’s certainly something we’ve worked on with Minister Burke to manage the number while we’ve been working on the longer term solution that will involve the use of ballots.  

Senator ROBERTS: It’s an attempt to temporarily limit numbers of persons entering Australia and to smooth out the application processing.  

Ms Sharp: Yes. It’s—  

Senator ROBERTS: You’ve got a varying load, by the sound of it, and you want to smooth it out.  

Ms Sharp: Yes. The challenge with the Working Holiday Maker program, prior to the government taking action this financial year, is that it is completely demand driven, which means that we’ve seen very rapid growth over several years, which led us to the situation where we had these historically high levels. The actions we’ve taken are seeking to moderate that growth and bring that level down somewhat, in the way that the minister has also talked through today. We’re looking at every visa class; it’s not just the Working Holiday Maker visa. That’s probably been the one most publicly commented on in the media, but there are other changes being made to student visas. We’re making changes to visitor visas. We’re making changes to the way our permanent program is allocated, all with the sole goal, if you like, of ensuring that the government has much better control over the number of people coming to and staying in Australia.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you. You want to restore control to immigration entry?  

Ms Sharp: We want to maintain control and, for some of these programs that have historically been completely demand driven, provide government with some levers to have control over numbers. In something like the Working Holiday Maker program, it has historically been a program where, however many people applied, if they met the criteria, they would be granted a visa.  

Senator ROBERTS: Does this apply to international students and their dependants and families? Does it apply to illegals and the unskilled?  

Ms Sharp: Certainly we are making changes. There have been a number of steps taken in relation to students over several years, and another round of changes was announced earlier this month. The most significant of those is restricting dependants accompanying students and temporary graduates—for most students, not all, but most. So, yes, certainly we are, as I said, looking across the system to make changes where they are sensible, moderate, and ensure government has levers to manage the volume.  

Senator ROBERTS: What about graduate students?  

Ms Sharp: Temporary graduates?  

Senator ROBERTS: Yes.  

Ms Sharp: Temporary graduates will be subject to similar controls to those we’re applying to students. Most temporary graduates will not, going forward, be able to have dependants attached to their visa.  

Senator ROBERTS: It sounds like One Nation policy that you’re adopting. Could we have a copy of a listing of the numbers, please, and the cuts in each area?  

Senator Watt: I’d love to see one of those from One Nation.  

Senator ROBERTS: We’ve shown it. I’ll get it to you.  

Senator Watt: Is that your version, Senator Hanson’s version or Mr Farley’s version?  

Senator ROBERTS: It’s the party’s version.  

Senator Watt: But I’ve seen about four or five. Which one should I look at?  

Senator ROBERTS: The one that was finalised.  

Senator Watt: Is that your version?  

Senator ROBERTS: I’ll send it to you. No, it’s the party’s version. Ms Sharp, I’m very pleased to hear this, but I won’t endorse it until I see the actual numbers, because the Labor Party has been frightened to address the numbers.  

Ms Sharp: Senator, we can take on notice the NOM effect of these measures.  

Senator ROBERTS: What effect? I’m sorry.  

Ms Sharp: The net overseas migration effect. What impact do we think these measures will have on net overseas migration? I would note that Senator Duniam also asked something similar, and there is an order for production seeking similar information as well. That’s currently being processed through our system.  

Senator ROBERTS: Could I have the existing numbers and the reduced numbers expected in future for each of the visa categories: main visa applicants, students, graduate students, dependants of students, dependants of graduate students, illegals, the unskilled and graduates?  

Ms Sharp: Yes. Illegals are a little different.  

Senator ROBERTS: Yes, that will be different.  

Ms Sharp: In that we don’t control—  

Senator ROBERTS: You know they’re there, but you haven’t chased them. Okay.  

Ms Sharp: That’s correct.  

Senator ROBERTS: Have applicants been notified of potential delays in the processing of visas?  

Mr Willard: Yes, Senator. There is information on our website that applicants receive that indicates they should expect three-month processing times.  

Senator ROBERTS: This policy is contributing to enlarging the backlog of visa applications waiting to be processed, I take it?  

Mr Willard: I gave you the figure for the on-hand number, which has risen over the last three months.  

Senator ROBERTS: Minister, will this mean the Labor Party will start to use the word ‘no’ and refuse people entry?  

Senator Watt: We already do that where someone seeking a visa doesn’t pass security tests or meet a range of other requirements.  

Senator ROBERTS: What is the number of backlogged initial applications and currently known appeals awaiting a decision? Do you have those numbers, or is that a question on notice?  

Ms Sharp: Across all visa types?  

Senator ROBERTS: Yes.  

Ms Sharp: Sorry, could you ask the question again, Senator?  

Senator ROBERTS: What is the number of backlogged initial applications and currently known appeals awaiting a decision?  

Ms Sharp: Across all visa classes? We would need to take that on notice.  

Senator ROBERTS: That will be fine. Shifting slightly, how common is visa hopping? It sounds pretty common from Ms Foster‘s nodding.  

Mr Willard: Visa hopping, as it’s referred to, is one of the practices that the changes that have been introduced are seeking to address. It refers to a circumstance where students, in particular, shift from visa to visa but never achieve completion of a course. In addition to the changes to dependence that Ms Sharp has outlined, there are also changes to the way in which people can apply for student visas onshore. That requires completion of a course and progression to a more advanced course. Those measures are designed to deal with that practice of visa hopping. In addition, the minister has announced that the visitor visas will be subject to a condition known as a ‘no further application’ or ‘no further stay’ condition, which means that only in exceptional circumstances would people be allowed to shift from a visitor visa to another visa while they’re onshore.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you. You may not know the answer to this one. What is the current number of non-citizens in Australia with no valid visa?  

Ms Sharp: Mr Thomas could probably come to the table and assist with that.  

Ms Foster: Noting these are estimates because, by the nature of that cohort, we’re not managing them on visas.  

Mr M Thomas: That’s right. At a point in time, 30 June this year, we estimate approximately 79,400 non citizens were here without a visa. That cohort is very fluid; it includes people that have been unlawful for a day, an hour, a week, a year. That cohort continuously changes as people become unlawful and subsequently leave the country as well.  

Senator ROBERTS: Well, that’s remarkable. It gives me confidence because we’ve been saying there are 80,000 people here illegally, and that’s pretty much the target. What measures—  

CHAIR: You are at time for your 10-minute block. Are you almost done, or is now a good time to rotate the call?  

Senator ROBERTS: Now would be a good time to rotate.  

CHAIR: Excellent. Thanks so much. Just indicating I’m going to share the call.  

Senator ROBERTS: If I could just add one more to that—  

CHAIR: Sure.  

Senator ROBERTS: How many non-citizens are currently here illegally? Is that different from the number who are here with no valid visa?  

Mr M Thomas: No, Senator. The number I gave you is the number of non-citizens that are here without a current valid visa.  

Senator Watt: Can I just add one thing on that. The government’s position is that, if someone doesn’t have a valid visa, they shouldn’t be here. That is why one of the other measures that’s just been announced by Minister Burke is an increase in what’s called compliance activity to remove people who don’t have a right to be here. Under the former government, funding was removed from that function.  

Senator ROBERTS: You’ve been here for half a decade.  

Senator Watt: I know.  

CHAIR: Senator Roberts.  

Senator Watt: I know you don’t like hearing things about your Liberal mates, but the truth is that, under the former government, funding to remove people who didn’t have a valid visa was wound down. We are putting that funding back in to remove people who don’t have a valid visa. 

Senator ROBERTS: And you’re chasing us because we introduced all these policies.  

Senator Watt: We’re not chasing you.  

Senator ROBERTS: Yes you are. We’re setting the agenda, Senator Watt.  

Senator Watt: We are not chasing you. 

Why we should never sacrifice the ‘eight keys of human progress’

We were born free. If politics continues its current trajectory though, people born today may be the last to make such a claim.

With great sadness I acknowledge the decline of liberty, and even more so the vigour with which many people cheer the end of freedom believing that something better awaits in the arms of extremists and socialists.

This is not an opinion. Polls across Western countries, including our own, show roughly half of all young people believe socialism offers a better framework of government than democracy.

Their reasons for believing this are vague because their education was dire.

To be frank, educators lied to them.

Radicalisation begins with the omission of knowledge. That’s why students shout, ‘Capitalism is fascism!’ whilst being unable to describe capitalism, explain how they are oppressed, or, if prompted, determine why the buying and selling of goods constitutes ‘fascism’.

Another word that activists fail to define.

When passionate activists don’t understand their own demands, we call it dogma.

I ask the Prime Minister how he intends to build a productive Australia with a workforce of young people who believe capitalism, pro-business, and pro-employment attitudes are a ‘threat to the working class’…

These young Australians remain free only because older generations outnumber them at the polling booth. When the oldies are gone, and Labor’s absurd inter-generational war has run its course, freedom will be voted out of power. It’s a tragedy I work to stop.

The problem, as far as I see it, is that the word ‘freedom’ remains all around us and yet very few feel any emotional connection to its meaning.

Children fear the message of the Climate Change movement. They receive social belonging from gender activism. Europe’s rioting students walked away with arms full of designer loot and TikTok fame following their carnage.

And race collectivists often benefit from the riches of public money and daily privilege. These things have tangible prizes.

What can freedom offer if it is already possessed?

It’s difficult to evoke a passionate love of freedom in those who have never lived without it. Harder still to convince people born three-generations deep in peace of what awaits when it’s lost.

This is why freedom’s greatest writers, those we quote, lived through history’s worst periods of terror.

One of the most enduring pens belongs to George Orwell who, like I, was born in India.

His path to freedom began with anti-imperialism, wandered through socialism, and emerged as a defence of Western capitalist democracy to the point he wished to be laid to rest in English soil.

Orwell watched the Left splinter and hunt itself down, with the ruling Stalinists killing the anarchists and socialists until shaking the hand of Hitler.

Watching this betrayal, Orwell noted that the newspapers of the day found safety in government-approved lies. The media feared Stalin. The people feared each other and the secret police. Oppression is more than violence. It’s the fear of breathing.

Australia is recreating a version of this through bureaucratic webs. The silk of censorship is spun above our media with tripwires, such as Section 18C, used to paralyse speech. Speakers fear the system consuming them – to be bound and left on display as a warning to others who might attempt to locate the spider at the centre of government.

Orwell was shot through the neck and, had he died in the trenches, the defenders of freedom would be without some of his greatest insights. In particular, Orwell recounted passing comrades on the street who treated him as a stranger… Political factions replaced their individual personality until only one identity remained … the State.

That’s how identity politics works. We saw it during Covid when friends, family, and colleagues turned cold to their humanity.

To successfully champion freedom, Orwell showed his audience its opposite: oppression.

The problem facing the defenders of freedom today is the cynical way in which the left fabricated Marxist ‘oppression’ narratives to falsely present our free country as a system of oppression that needs to be dismantled.

Students living in the most liberal state of human existence genuinely believe themselves to be suffering such terrible constriction that the entire nation must be ripped apart to satisfy their desire to ‘be free’. To be ‘free’ of ‘freedom’…

How do we begin to counteract such a deep level of delusion?

Freedom’s curse is that it can only be felt at the moment of its achievement. Stepping out of a cell. Dropping a weight. Those who were never incarcerated or made to carry a load don’t understand. Just as the young don’t value the privilege of waking without the pain, life experience, and wisdom of age.

At the end of his ideological journey, Orwell meditated on the destruction of language – what we may call censorship – being the final veil set over a nation’s eyes. This culminated in Nineteen-eighty-four, his last and most famous novel.

With deep concern we watch politicians take cavalier stabs at social media, mostly in self-defence against criticism. To my colleagues I say this: viewing public speech as an adversary, even as an enemy, is a childish, fear-filled, and irresponsible position for those elected to serve.

The following eight key insights to human progress are themselves descendants of freedom.

Freedom: This includes freedom of speech – yet is so much more.

Freedom comprises:

  • Freedom to live, freedom of life – without which every other freedom doesn’t matter.
  • Freedom of thought (without indoctrination).
  • Freedom of belief, faith, and religious practice.
  • Freedom of speech to share thoughts, faith, ideas and opportunities.
  • Freedom of initiative and freedom to innovate – to make products and services, to organise, and structure systems, to build communities.
  • Freedom to compete and improve outcomes, products, services – a wellspring of human progress.
  • Freedom of association to mingle with whomever we choose.
  • Freedom of exchange and trade.
  • Freedom of movement, travel.
  • Freedom to explore ideas, opportunities, alternative societies.
  • Freedom of choice in how we spend our resources, time, and purchases.

Choice is fundamental for accountability, efficiency and progress.

Millions of free hearts and minds in a free market where people are free to exchange make far better decisions and superior resource allocation than do bureaucrats in remote, isolated ivory towers. The freedom to choose and compete underpins the structure of markets. Markets are the way human technology and ideas advance.

Without competition, there is no progress. We must be free to innovate, initiate, share, and act. To meet people’s real needs, not bureaucratic fancies and dictates.

Free choice is vital for releasing the innate human drive for human progress … personal, community, national, social.

Without speech, we can barely think. Without thought, we can never dream or create or truly operate as individuals or exercise choice.

Throughout history, periods in which freedom flourish show how wonderful humanity can be with three of our traits unique to our species … reasoning, care going beyond nurture in animal species, and love.

Contrast these periods with periods of suppression under ego-driven totalitarians’ rampant illogic, careless self-centred disregard for others, and fear.

The rule of law

Stable, small governments that properly constrain the ambition of power in those few humans whose fears drive them to seek control over others. In governments that remain capable of performing basic tasks enabling individual freedom.

They do this through offering external security, domestic safety, and fair rules within which competition and choice can take place. The perception of fairness and implementation of justice prevents endless demands and revenge eating through society.

Stable governance

Continuity of stable governance is essential for human progress and for security. Our Australian Constitution embraces the core tenet of competitive federalism, being a marketplace of governance providing choice and, via choice, providing real accountability. Compliance with our Constitution is thus a high priority after decades of executive governments, parliaments, and High Court decisions centralising power and finances through denying states’ rights.

And conversion of competitive federalism with its inherent accountability into competitive welfarism giving Premiers and Prime Ministers plenty of opportunities to hide … and remove accountability.

Sovereignty is a subset of governance. No society can be free if their nation is a prisoner of another. That doesn’t mean being part of an empire or commonwealth. It means foolishly, even traitorously handing federal and state policymaking and the allocation of resources to unelected and dishonest United Nations bureaucracies lacking accountability.

It can mean being the prisoner of coercive trade partnerships such as what careless politicians have allowed to happen with Australia and China. When even our defence decisions result in economic punishment and diplomatic threats, we’re not free to make our own decisions.

Secure private property rights

To maintain freedom, people must believe that what they spend their lives earning is theirs. This acts as motivation to excel, contribute, build, and to freely share.

Humans with something of value to defend choose to prioritise peace more than those with nothing except what the state hands out. If it’s not earned, it’s not valued. This applies to the accumulation of savings and other assets.

Strong families

Families bind free societies together. They are the root of value structures. A person’s connection to their ancestors and thus, to their nation. Families moderate the desire for capital with the emotional value of someone else to enrich with those earnings.

Families create compassion across generations, class, religion, and industry.

A city voter with rural grandparents, for example, is more likely to vote against policies fashioned for city-based identity politics if the same policy hurts food producers in the regions. Families arguably dilute the corrosive power of identity politics.

Strong families offer people somewhere to set their heart because human beings are a deeply social species and most have a deeply ingrained need for belonging.

Governments who encourage people to view the state as family become, themselves, heartless. A political system can never love us back.

Affordable energy

Cheap, reliable, stable, secure energy is essential for competitiveness, high standards of living, security, and the hallmarks of modern, productive, safe, and comfortable society.

Honest taxation

axes are one of the many prices we pay for government. Taxation must be honest, efficient, fair, and productive. Excess taxes are the result of wasteful spending and lack of public scrutiny.

Honest money

Money serves many noble and essential roles. Today, money is not backed with tangible assets and is thus easily corrupted and not seen as robust.

Today, taxation and money are not honest. This removes justice, fairness and accountability, diminishes choice, and puts a severe brake on human progress and freedom.

Money and taxation are topics for another day. Suffice to say that low taxes, value for resources, and honest money are all essential tools in the creation of a society with enough prosperity to allow freedom to flourish.

Returning to Australia’s youth …

What often confuses those watching school protests is how often the word ‘freedom’ is thrown around. The definition matters.

Their vision of freedom often means ‘the freedom to oppress others using the power of the government’.

Offensive people and ideas can be shut down for ‘safety’.

It’s the liberty of a nest where government authority replaces the role of the parent for a generation coddled too tightly.

This is the ‘freedom’ of those who are abusing authority.

They feel liberated because they have that ‘power’.

What these misguided students don’t realise is that collectivism teaches a selfish cannibalistic miscarriage of freedom. One that prioritises the freedom of government at the expense of individual liberty until the natural conclusion of all collectivist states emerges – limitless government.

The lesson of history is that governments themselves, as an institution, should never be free. Citizens are jailers of their government. We citizens hold all the keys and turn them at election.

Additionally, between elections, we must actively hold our elected representatives accountable … daily. These are the only ways. This was the lesson of the Glorious Revolution in England that created the strange Catch-22 of power that kept Australia stable for hundreds of years.

Even with a near-perfect blueprint for government, freedom can only be properly realised when paired with meaning. The freedom is for something and toward something. A free individual alone in barbarity is oppressed through their isolation.

A society with purpose and culture is one where individuals can truly be free.

We have lost some of this purpose.

Australians are now taught to hate our history, our ancestors, our achievements, our prosperity, our ideas, our skin, our sex or gender, our family, and even the concept of Australia.

It’s oppression through collective guilt disguised as ‘liberation from evil colonialism, imperialism, and capitalism’. All of it radical nonsense that activists push, mostly for money.

Thanks to them, our youth have a corrupted misunderstanding of freedom. As parents, grandparents and leaders, we have not spent enough time de-radicalising youth from the poison of the power-seeking education system which has been left shamefully unattended with an ulterior motive. Indoctrination stole their precious freedom of thought.

The best protection we can give the next generation for a time when we are gone and unable to defend them, is to plant the root of liberty in the corner of their minds.

This is what I believe.

Freedom is not the ordinary human condition, and yet it is our universal and natural right.

Freedom is what weak, fearful, ego-driven humans have denied each other in almost every chapter of our long history.

Remember, always beneath control there is … fear.

Despite this, freedom is the spark that ignited the Enlightenment, as a grand civilisational movement, and as the first idea that set us apart from the rest of the animal kingdom. It’s the basis of competition and choice from competition came every technological advance, every work of art, every language, and every free market.

Every human progress began as a free thought, unencumbered from the State.

The concept of being a free individual was a revelation. It broke us out of restrictive collective thinking that, while useful to survive in isolation, kept us from the extraordinary civilisation we eventually built.

Sometimes it’s easier to think of collectivism as a life-raft. An emergency adaptation of temporary collaboration. When that life-raft reaches a safe shore, those who remain inside its tight control starve to death. This is how an overattachment to a narrow understanding of safetyism kills.

For most political and religious regimes, the concept of freedom is viewed as a threat to power, and so it is repressed.

Australians face a different problem. Having been born as a free-range people, some members of our Uniparty Morrison and Albanese governments attempted, for the first time, to herd us into the cage.

People who can see the bars shout and bravely face being silenced. The rest, sadly the majority, are lured into the cage with handouts and promises of petty power.

It’s the moral confusion between freedom and free stuff.

The first has no monetary value … it’s priceless. The latter costs everything.

The value of freedom to the security and prosperity of Australia is a topic I have spoken on many times throughout my years in Parliament including two re-elections.

I hope that this time, it’s understood that the challenges of our time cannot be solved through the misery of collective oppression that the ‘left’ prescribes and some members of the ‘right’ ignorantly wave through.

The problems of today could not be solved through the misery of collective oppression.

It was US President Madison who said, ‘Popular government without popular education is the prologue to farce or a tragedy.’

And so it is with Australia.

Let us remind our children of another innate truth; history repeatedly shows that tension and conflict are resolved best with more freedom, not less.

The Australia Institute recently claimed that big government serves everyday Australians while small government only serves the rich. The point was to attack One Nation’s “neoliberal” policies. They completely miss our core belief that an economy run for the benefit of the people creates growth and abundance so Australians can be self-sufficient and independent. It’s not about the size of government, it’s about what government actually does.

The left hates economic independence because self-sufficient Australians don’t rely on the state. That’s why the Australia Institute is pushing destructive measures like an inheritance tax on lifetime savings and a 2% wealth tax on assets over $5 million. Not income – assets! These taxes hit asset-rich, cash-poor Australians hard; our farmers, truckers, fishers and small business owners, which will force many into bankruptcy.

One Nation firmly rejects both wealth and inheritance taxes. The Albanese Labor government has already embraced these left-wing ideas, pushing capital gains tax changes that crashed housing prices, erased billions in national wealth and trapped young buyers in negative equity.

Labor needs to stop pushing ideology over economics.

Bring on the next election so One Nation can put an end to this socialist agenda once and for all.

Transcript

Senator Roberts: Last month, the Australia Institute stated that big government serves the interests of everyday Australians and small government only serves the rich. The point was to attack as ‘neoliberal’ policies that One Nation is promoting. It fails to understand One Nation’s central belief that an economy run for the benefit of the people will grow wealth and abundance for all, reducing the need for government support as people take care of themselves. It fails to understand that it’s not the size of government but what government does that counts. The Australia Institute advocates an inheritance tax to target, in their words, ‘the untaxed compounding of intergenerational wealth’. One Nation calls that wealth that parents build up during a lifetime of hard work ‘people getting ahead’. That’s what it is. It’s what parents do: work hard and pass the benefit to their children. 

The political left hate people becoming self-sufficient, because economic resilience removes subservience to government. The fundamental difference between One Nation and Labor-Greens socialism is economic independence. Small business is in the Australia Institute’s sights, with a proposed two per cent wealth tax on assets over $5 million. Not income—assets. The losers from this include farmers, truckers, restaurants, fishers, fast food franchisees and childcare workers. These Australians are asset rich and income poor. Paying a $100,000 annual tax would force them out of business. 

One Nation rejects a wealth tax and an inheritance tax. The Albanese Labor government listened to the Australia Institute when they advocated recent capital gains tax changes. The Treasurer needs to stop pushing socialism. Founded on ideology not economics, these changes have caused a housing price crash, wiping billions from our national estate and placing many young Australians who used the five per cent deposit scheme in negative equity. Thanks, Treasurer. Now please stop helping. Enough! Bring on the next election so that One Nation can slay the socialist dragon.

The Greens are trying to force higher taxes onto Australia’s resource sector and I have to ask: how much is enough?

With the mining, oil and gas industries contributing $45 billion in taxes and royalties last year alone and $335 billion over the past five years, true economic growth comes from expanding, not shutting down, natural resource projects.

A recent meeting with Tamboran in the Northern Territory emphasised the life-changing impact of resource jobs for regional and Aboriginal communities. Providing real skills, stable incomes and financial independence, these projects offer a path out of welfare dependency and toward home ownership and prosperity.

Everyday Australians already see returns in their superannuation from our resource industry, while governments receive critical royalties to fund essential public services, as well as the “free stuff” they love to dish out. The Beetaloo project is already attracting interest from data centres seeking direct access to the Northern Territory’s national internet backbone. With guaranteed gas for power and water for cooling, planning could begin today.

This is One Nation’s approach: maximising resource development for the benefit of all Australians, while maintaining genuine, practical environmental protections. We will focus on our real landscape, not the climate orthodoxy pushed by Labor, the Greens, Teals and globalist Liberals.

Blocking new coal, gas and mine extensions will crush jobs and cripple regional towns. The Federal Court’s recent decision to overturn the government’s ban on the $1.3 billion McPhillamys goldmine reaffirms One Nation’s commitment to sound, responsible resource extraction that delivers long-term abundance for all Australians.

Taxing the resource industry into extinction while expecting it to fund the nation is pure madness!

Transcript

Senator Roberts: I thank Senator McKim for this motion. The first thought I had after reading this motion was simply ‘how much is enough?’ The resource industry, mining, oil and gas paid $45 billion last year in company tax and royalties in Australia. Over the last five years, they’ve contributed $335 billion in tax. If the Greens want even more, there is a simple way to achieve that: more mines, more gas wells, more utilisation of Australia’s immense natural resources to bring in taxation and to create the wealth and opportunity for all who are here, especially in rural and remote areas where the workforce has a large Aboriginal component. 

My office met this afternoon with Tamboran, who operate a new gas well in the Northern Territory, and included hearing about their successful Aboriginal employment program. Tamboran are giving Aboriginals breadwinner jobs, training and a future independent of government handouts, empowering Aboriginal workers to break free of welfare dependency. I can see why the Greens don’t like it. Who knows? Once Aboriginals own their own homes, are married with families and enjoying the benefits of resource job brings, they may vote One Nation. 

Resources already provide returns into their superannuation funds of everyday Australians, as well as extra royalty into government coffers, to pay for the free stuff that government offers. The Beetaloo project has already attracted inquiries from data centres looking for a location connected to the national internet backbone, which is the Northern Territory. Data centres could start planning today, knowing the gas for power and the water for cooling are available. This is One Nation’s solution: more resource utilisation for the benefit of all Australians while, of course, ensuring the protection of our natural environment—the natural environment, not the sky god of warming as Labor, Greens, teals and globalist Liberals still believe. The green solution is to tax the resource industry while shutting down the resource industry. This is insane. Yes, I know it doesn’t make any sense to me. 

Published Greens party policy is no new coal, no new gas and no extensions to coal or gas leases. High taxes will force resource projects out of business and, importantly to the Greens, prevent new developments. Massive job losses will result from this Greens party policy. Huge communities will be cast into poverty, heat and isolation because wind and solar are a useless way to drive air conditioners, transport and industry. Government revenue to pay for all the free stuff goes, and superannuation returns fall, and the Greens celebrated the refusal of a $1.3 billion extension to the McPhillamys goldmine in New South Wales. The reason Minister Plibersek gave for the refusal was the section 10 Aboriginal protection order, as the site hosted a mythical blue-banded bee important to Aboriginal culture, apparently. 

Today, the Federal Court officially overturned the mining ban. Justice James Stellios ruled that Minister Plibersek’s protection order was legally invalid due to a procedural failure and a lack of procedural fairness. The company that owns the mine paid $900 million in taxes last year on other projects. The taxes on this mine will be in the hundreds of millions of dollars. Who knows, there may be enough to cover the operating losses of one of Senator McKim’s Greens supermarkets. 

This motion shows the stark contrast between the Greens and One Nation. The Greens will use high taxes to force resource companies out of business in the name of social justice virtue signalling while One Nation will encourage environmentally sound resource extraction in the name of providing abundance for everyday Australians for many, many, many years to come. Voters of Australia, the choice is yours. 

Great Australian Infrastructure (GAIN), led by a consortium of major Australian companies, would add over $100 billion to Australia’s GDP and create 40,000 vital “breadwinner” jobs. This project would deliver essential transport, power, water, and internet connectivity across northern Australia, helping to lift remote Aboriginal communities out of poverty.

I questioned Minister Farrell (representing the Minister for Northern Australia) about the long-delayed GAIN proposal, which has been sitting with the Northern Australia Infrastructure Facility (NAIF) for over two months despite proponents providing all requested information.

Minister Farrell acknowledged the ambition of the transcontinental rail proposal (from the Pilbara to the Bowen Basin) yet shrugged off the delay, comparing it historically to the decades it took to build the Alice Springs-to-Darwin railway.

Why is the supposed “party of the worker” dragging its feet on a project that would create tens of thousands of jobs in mining, steel, ceramics and cement vital for housing construction?

The government’s inaction regarding this vital infrastructure project is baffling. GAIN would provide basic utilities, fresh food and improved market access for Indigenous cattle graziers, improving the current appalling living conditions in remote communities.

Minister Farrell conceded that the proposal’s aims were worthwhile and agreed to personally make inquiries to see where the project’s assessment is up to and get back to me.

Update: Thank you to the Minister for achieving a result. With the NAIF providing clear direction, the ball is now in the project sponsor’s court.

I look forward to continuing to work with the Government to bring this incredibly beneficial project to life.

Transcript

Senator ROBERTS: My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Northern Australia, Senator Farrell. Minister, the great Australian infrastructure project—  

Honourable senators interjecting—  

The PRESIDENT: Order! Senator Roberts, please resume your seat. Order across the chamber. I need to be able to hear the question. Senator Roberts, I’m going to invite you to start again, and I expect there to be silence.  

Senator ROBERTS: Thank you, President. There’ll be no welcome to country. My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Northern Australia, Senator Farrell. The great Australian infrastructure project, GAIN, proposal has been with the Northern Australia Infrastructure Facility for more than two months now. The proponents have provided all the information the NAIF requested.  

This proposal is coming from a consortium of leading Australian companies, some publicly listed, who have the expertise and resources including funding to progress this project. The GAIN project will add more than $100 billion to Australia’s GDP, provide 40,000 breadwinner jobs and provide transport, power, water and internet access across northern Australia, including lifting remote Aboriginal communities out of poverty through improved market access, town services and tourism.  

Minister, will you undertake to work with the NAIF to progress GAIN as a matter of urgency?  

Senator FARRELL (Minister for Trade and Tourism, Special Minister of State and Deputy Leader of the Government in the Senate): I thank Senator Roberts for his intriguing question and thank him for the advance notice, which gives me an opportunity to give a very factual response.  

Senator Scarr: As opposed to usual.  

Senator FARRELL: That is very unkind. Look, I could be hurt by something like that, but I won’t take offence. So just as to make sure I understand this particular project, the idea behind this particular project, is to run a transcontinental railway line from Pilbara through to the Bowen Basin. That’s the proposal we’re talking about here, I think. Senator Roberts, just to make sure—?  

The PRESIDENT: Senator Farrell, Senator Roberts has asked a fulsome question. It’s not question and answer. Thank you for standing, Senator Roberts, but I’m going to ask the minister to continue.  

Senator FARRELL: Well, let’s assume for the purpose of the debate—and perhaps in your subsequent question, you can answer that question—if this item has only recently been put forward to the NAIF then I don’t think the proponents on a proposal like this, a very dramatic big-picture proposal, should necessarily expect a response in weeks. It obviously is a very ambitious project. I can recall when South Australia handed back the Northern Territory to the federal government in 1911, the condition was that the railway line between Alice Springs and Darwin would be completed and that took another 80 years to happen, so these big-picture proposals don’t occur overnight. But can I say this— (Time expired)  

The PRESIDENT: Senator Roberts, a first supplementary? 

Senator ROBERTS: The mining industry employs 314,000 Australians directly and 800,000 indirectly. These are largely breadwinner jobs that create families. Many are union members. Minister, why is the supposed party of the worker showing no interest in a project that will create tens of thousands of breadwinner jobs in mining, steel, ceramics, fertiliser, industrial gas—including oxygen—and cement, which we badly need for housing construction and to revitalise the productivity in this country?  

Senator FARRELL: I would hope all of the jobs would be union jobs, not just some—the Australian Workers’ Union, I suppose, a very good union, a very fine union actually, come to think of it. All of those things that you’ve just mentioned are really, really good things for this country to be doing and, I would imagine, would be the sorts of things that the NAIF is interested in. But the NAIF has an independent board process that assesses all project financing applications against its investment mandate and rigorous due diligence requirements. You wouldn’t want a project that can’t be successful to be supported by public funds, I’m sure. These processes can take some time, and as the NAIF very, very diligently manages public funds— (Time expired)  

The PRESIDENT: Senator Roberts, second supplementary? 

Senator ROBERTS: Aboriginal communities across the Top End are living in appalling conditions. The GAIN project will bring transport, town water, electricity, internet, fresh food and market access to more than 100 remote communities. It will facilitate movement of cattle to port in a way that does not stress the animal and improve returns to Aboriginal communities who rely on grazing for their income. Minister, why is the government not interested in a real project to change the lives of Aboriginals in remote communities?  

Senator FARRELL: Senator Roberts, this government is interested in doing exactly what you say in Indigenous communities around the country. Obviously, if this project could help those people, then that’s a very good thing. Given your interest in this, Senator Roberts, I shall personally make some inquiries to see whether or not I can find out where this proposal is up to. It’s a very ambitious proposal. I think you’re being a little bit unrealistic in how quickly you can expect a response, but, nevertheless, I shall take it upon myself to make an inquiry to see where it’s up to and I shall come back to you personally on this issue as soon as I can.  

Schedule 4 of The Aged Care Legislation Amendment (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Aged Care Commissioner and Other Measures) Bill 2026 was added to address the government’s secret rollout of AI algorithms to assess aged-care applications. For the past year, human assessors were strictly prohibited from overriding computer decisions (even when clinically wrong), leading to under-assessments, long waiting lists and a sixfold surge in appeals, with elderly Australians dying before their reviews were resolved.

One Nation believes that although AI can be used for background legwork, it must never be allowed to make final, unreviewable decisions over human lives. We will legislate to ban fully automated government decision-making.

This AI decision-making system is part of a broader pattern of attacks by the Albanese Government on our elderly, including:

❌ Reducing health insurance rebates, pushing up to 75,000 pensioners into the public system and costing taxpayers approximately an extra $2 billion annually.

❌ Attempting to impose co-contributions on basic personal care (which they were forced to roll back).

❌ Increasing means-tested accommodation fees and daily living costs for retirees.

❌ Creating backlogs through the Support at Home framework.

❌ Raising Centrelink deeming rates by 0.5%, effectively reducing pensions based on assumed, unearned interest.

❌ Capping allied health services for older veterans at $5,000 (which the Senate successfully blocked).

Basically stealing money from pensioners!

Finally, I foreshadowed a second reading amendment regarding Voluntary Assisted Dying. While VAD is legal across all Australian states, state laws currently force aged-care facilities to allow external VAD practitioners onto their premises.

My amendment does not restrict VAD access for individuals; rather, it protects the freedom of conscience and religion for faith-based aged-care providers by allowing them to conscientiously object and opt out of facilitating VAD on-site, provided residents are informed and assisted with transfers to participating facilities. Based on the sensible South Australian model, this ensures respect for differing moral convictions in our community.

Transcript

Senator Roberts: The Aged Care Legislation Amendment (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Aged Care Commissioner and Other Measures) Bill 2026 amends the Aged Care Act 2024 to, firstly, establish yet another permanent statutory office, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Aged Care Commissioner, within the Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission; secondly, to incorporate temporary modifications made to the Aged Care (Consequential and Transitional Provisions) (Aged Care System Modification) Rules 2025 into the Aged Care Act and Aged Care Rules 2025 and repeal the instrument; and, thirdly, to vary arrangements concerning refundable deposits, including their use while an individual awaits a means-test assessment, the ability to transfer deposits between providers and the treatment of deposits in aged-care means-testing. One Nation is in support of these long-overdue changes. Fourthly, it will make other administrative and regulatory amendments concerning direct-care staff, local government providers, specialised residential care homes, residential care subsidies, fee advice notices, deemed decisions and the recovery of Commonwealth overpayments.  

This bill has been referred to two committees for reporting—the second because the government added a new schedule late in the passage of the bill. Both reports recommend the bill be passed. I note once again that the Labor government has packaged something we do agree with—the improvements and technical clean-up in schedules 2, 3 and 4 of the bill—with something we do not agree with, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Aged Care Commissioner. This is designed to force One Nation to oppose the bill and, in so doing, provide social media fodder for the ALP and the Greens at the next election. They want to claim One Nation opposed reforms to help our elderly. It’s a wedge, another bloody wedge—one of the many wedges this cynical Labor government have used lately to entertain themselves while everyday Australians continue to go backwards. You don’t care about the people.  

One Nation has moved an amendment on sheet No. 4177 to remove the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander commissioner provisions and leave the remainder of the bill intact. One Nation opposes discriminating against Australians based on physical characteristics, including ethnicity, age, sex, sexual orientation and disability. Positive discrimination is still discrimination. It seeks to present a morally superior position which inevitably fails in a perfect storm of cost escalation, empire building, self-interest, mission creep and unexpected consequences that the taxpayers pay for.  

According to the Guardian newspaper, Aboriginal children in Australia have historically been murdered at roughly three times the rate of non-Aboriginal counterparts—three times. Aboriginal children experience rape at five times the rate of non-Aboriginal children, a figure that’s underreported to the point of official data being useless—bloody useless. Aboriginal children are being left in squalor without adult supervision. All of this is under the watchful gaze of the virtue-signalling elites who advance bills like this and then crack open the chardonnay to celebrate how worthy they are. This government and state governments won’t stop Aboriginal children being raped and murdered, yet they have the money for a dedicated Aboriginal aged-care commissioner and their staff. This will of course lead to more regulations and higher costs for everyone. The entire idea, of course, will have no KPIs—not one—to measure progress, because for Labor it’s not about the outcome; it’s about feelings. 

We do not need an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Aged Care Commissioner. We need our aged-care system to support everyone that it’s tasked with supporting. A One Nation government will send its attorney-general into Aboriginal communities, along with ministers for housing, health and infrastructure, to fix the crime and the structural problems behind these heartbreaking, unacceptable statistics—unacceptable to most Australians but not the government.  

We will create jobs to restore the future of Aboriginal communities, using mining and value-adding of raw production, including in agriculture. We will oversee Australia’s largest infrastructure project, the northern rail crossing from east to west, part of the national rail loop, to bring rail transport, water, electricity and the internet to remote communities. That’s our idea of helping the Aboriginal community, not this window dressing BS. 

Anyone who thinks this is a good idea need only look at Closing the Gap. A measure there intended to reduce the life expectancy gap between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal Australians has in part failed, completely failed, with life expectancy in recent data getting worse for Aboriginals, not better. An analysis of government outlays over the first eight years of the strategy alone, from 2008 to 2016, calculated that total combined spending towards meeting the Closing the Gap targets exceeded—wait for it—$130.2 billion. The source of that data is Adam Creighton in the Australian quoting the Productivity Commission data on 12 February 2018. The Productivity Commission estimated in 2017 that federal government spending on Aboriginal affairs was $25 billion a year. I see nothing to suggest that that number has been going down since then. And then add the state spending. 

I hope the Senate will realise it’s time to change course on the Aboriginal industry. Stop funding more parasites in consultants, academics, lawyers, bureaucrats and larger top-end supervisors. Instead, directly fund the communities where it’s needed. I’ll say it again. This is what we’re advocating: instead of the parasites getting the money, let’s get it to the communities, to fund the communities, where it’s needed directly. 

Moving on, the new schedule 4, added in the House of Reps, makes changes to take account of criticism of the government’s use of AI for decision-making. Applications for aged care have for the last year been determined using AI, not human beings. The Albanese government implemented a system last year which featured strict prohibition of human override. Expert, qualified human-needs assessors were explicitly barred from altering or overriding the algorithm’s outputs, even when they knew a decision was clinically wrong. Second was the systemic under-assessment of vulnerable people. Critics noted that the rigid computer program frequently failed to capture the complex realities of ageing, leaving vulnerable older Australians without adequate funding or essential homecare packages. Without their packages—so much for care! Third was the lack of consultation and transparency. The automated tool was introduced quietly with no public consultation, no industry trials and no transparency regarding the underlying algorithm—no openness; just a secretive AI. Fourth was the severe bureaucratic backlogs. Appeals against robodecisions ballooned sixfold after the system rolled out, meaning many elderly citizens faced extensive waiting lists, with some tragically dying before their reviews were resolved. Robo decision-making is a counterproductive efficiency measure, and I wonder about the real motivation for robo decision-making. 

This Labor government has declared war on the elderly. Just listen to these: removing their health insurance discount rebate, forcing more elderly Australians into the public health system and, in the end, costing taxpayers at least $2 billion more a year in public health to save $350 million on the rebate. That $2 billion figure is likely conservative, with up to 75,000 elderly Australians being forced to give up private health, almost double the government estimate—your estimate, doubled. The Albanese government tried to introduce co-contributions on personal care for aged pensioners. This was so badly received that the government backed down—you backed down—and agreed that vital personal care, like bathing and dressing, would not require out-of-pocket fees. Increased costs for capital and daily living—self-funded retirees and part pensioners must pay significantly higher means tested fees for everyday accommodation, capital contributions and clinical assistance. 

The Support at Home mess—the government absorbed existing homecare packages into the new Support at Home framework. Seniors groups have heavily criticised the measure for severe package backlogs, long wait times and plans to fold the entry-level Commonwealth Home Support Program into it, which critics say threatens independent living in regional and remote communities. The government lifted social security deeming rates by 0.5 per cent—half a per cent!—which means that, even if pensioners’ bank accounts are not yielding high interest, Centrelink now legally assumes they are anyway and adds made up unpaid interest to their income, reducing their pension. That’s what you’re doing. You’re basically stealing money from pensioners. For older veterans reliant on specialised treatments, the government produced a $5,000 annual cap on allied health services. Older veterans who require year-round support were told to pay for it themselves—’Just pay for it yourself’—a measure that the Senate forced the government to withdraw. It’s no wonder the government wanted to use robo decision-making to deflect the blame for this attack on elderly Australians away from themselves—cowardly, dishonest, a lie. 

Schedule 4 in this bill will help in improving rules around robodecisions. It must be the law that any decision taken using AI be subject to human review. A One Nation government will introduce legislation to prevent computerised decision-making anywhere in the government. AI can do the legwork, sure. It should never, though, be used to make a decision, let alone make final decisions that a qualified staff member cannot overturn when an error is detected. 

I foreshadow second reading amendment 4176, which has been advanced in response to many constituent concerns around the expansion of and advocacy for voluntary assisted dying. Voluntary assisted dying is now legal in all states. Nothing in our amendment advocates against voluntary assisted dying occurring. It simply seeks to protect aged-care providers who have a conscientious objection to providing voluntary assisted dying services on their premises. A religious objection is the most common conscientious objection. New South Wales, Queensland and South Australia have a law in place which explicitly regulates institutional objections. They mandate that residential aged-care facilities must not block external voluntary assisted dying practitioners from entering the premises. Because an aged-care room is legally considered a resident’s home, facilities are required to allow all stages of the voluntary assisted dying process, from consultations to death, to take place onsite. In Ontario and British Columbia, provincial governments in Canada have removed the right for aged-care facilities and hospitals to refuse voluntary assisted dying. This is very troubling to me, and it’s troubling my constituents. Our amendment seeks to provide support for aged-care facilities with encouragement that they’re not alone and to hold the line and uphold their convictions. 

This amendment is not about voluntary assisted dying as much as it’s about freedom of conscience and freedom of religion. Currently, in South Australia, healthcare providers can opt out of voluntary assisted dying if they advise residents that the facility does not offer voluntary assisted dying. This allows the resident a transfer to a facility that does offer voluntary assisted dying. My amendment reflects this sensible compromise. The South Australian model works and should be the national model. In the very difficult, emotive space of euthanasia, it’s very important to respect the differing views in the community and to allow residents to choose a non-voluntary-assisted-dying facility if they so want and for providers to opt out of voluntary assisted dying if it conflicts with their values. I ask the Senate to support my amendment 4176. 

The Vote